Former Premier League referee Dermot Gallagher has offered his expert analysis on several contentious incidents from the Boxing Day fixtures, providing clarity on decisions that have ignited debate among fans and players alike. His insights, reported by Sky Sports, delve into the intricacies of officiating in high-pressure situations.
One of the most significant incidents involved Aston Villa's Jhon Duran, who was shown a straight red card following an altercation with Newcastle's Fabian Schar. Referee Anthony Taylor's decision, made promptly after the incident, has prompted Villa manager Unai Emery to announce plans for an appeal against Duran's three-match suspension. Gallagher stated, "I thought it was a red card. People say he's off balance because Schar's pulling him and that there's always going to be contact, but I thought he could avoid that." He praised Taylor for his ability to assess the situation in real-time, without the aid of VAR monitors, and noted that the VAR review corroborated Taylor's decision. Gallagher suggested that even had Taylor been directed to the monitor, he would likely have upheld the red card.
Another incident that caught Gallagher's attention was the caution issued to Newcastle's Joelinton just before half-time. He remarked on the referee's handling of the situation, saying, "Whether he should have taken action against Rogers is debatable. He certainly doesn't hit him in the face; it's not violent, but the player doesn't have to do that."
Gallagher also addressed Bruno Fernandes' second yellow card during Manchester United's match against Wolverhampton. He explained, "When you make a tackle like the first one, you're always going to get a yellow card. It's a bog standard one. Tony Harrington did very well; he's really growing in confidence." Gallagher expressed confusion over Fernandes' decision to commit the second foul, labelling it an avoidable yellow-card offence.
On the topic of Wolves' goal from a corner against Manchester United, Gallagher defended Matt Doherty's positioning, asserting, "Matt Doherty has every right to stand where he does. He doesn't do anything wrong." He highlighted that Manchester United goalkeeper Andre Onana's push on Doherty played a role in the goal.
Gallagher also commented on other notable incidents, including the overturned red card for West Ham’s Guido Rodriguez, which he deemed a success for VAR. "One hundred per cent. This is where VAR really, really works," he affirmed, indicating that the initial decision had been incorrect.
Regarding Djed Spence's sending off for a second yellow card, Gallagher noted, "He doesn't need to do it. It's not wise at 90+4; no need to do it." He emphasised that Spence's earlier actions ultimately led to his dismissal.
In discussing Tottenham's penalty appeal against Nottingham Forest and Fraser Forster's handling outside the area, Gallagher maintained that the decisions were appropriate. "He would be so angry if a penalty was given for this. It just hits him; we all know he can't move his arm, so it can't be a penalty," he explained.
Finally, Gallagher addressed the offside controversy during Liverpool's match against Leicester, where the lengthy delay in decision-making raised eyebrows. He concluded, "There were two checks; that's why it took so long. People say it's infuriating, but this is what the people asked for. We have come a long way in five years."
Gallagher's reflections provide a comprehensive understanding of the complexities and challenges referees face in making crucial decisions during high-stakes matches, highlighting the fine line between controversy and clarity in the beautiful game.